What I Owe Someone Who Takes My Advice

We can become comfortable explaining an idea before we can practise it. On the responsibility that comes with giving advice, and being clear about what it rests on.

हिंदी में पढ़ें

I think it is possible to become comfortable explaining an idea before we become capable of practising it.

We read about it. We discuss it. We find better examples and clearer words. People begin to appreciate how we explain it, and gradually we become someone others approach for guidance.

That brings a responsibility I want to examine carefully.

What can someone actually see in my work or my conduct that gives them a reason to trust what I am saying?

I keep thinking about a simple example. Imagine someone who can explain how to ride a bicycle. They understand balance, describe the movement of the pedals and know what a beginner is likely to struggle with.

Then someone brings a bicycle and asks them to ride.

At that moment, the question becomes concrete. Can they demonstrate what they have been explaining?

In our working lives, the bicycle is often missing.

We speak about leadership, trust, responsibility and collaboration. These words matter, but it can take time for someone to see how we practise them. A convincing conversation may come much earlier than that opportunity.

Suppose I advise a founder to delegate more.

“Trust your team” is easy to say. The founder may agree with it completely. What they need help with is what happens next.

Which decisions should the team be able to make? What information do they need? What happens when they choose an approach the founder would not have chosen? How should the founder respond when a mistake becomes expensive?

If I am offering guidance, I want to be able to stay with those questions. I should be able to explain what I have tried, what happened, where I struggled and what remains unresolved.

The other person should also be able to ask how much of my experience applies to their situation. Something that worked in one team may depend on conditions we have not yet understood.

Giving advice asks us to take an interest in those conditions.

The person receiving it may change how they manage their team, spend their time or approach an important relationship. They will live with the consequences after our conversation ends.

That makes me want to be more precise about the basis of what I say.

Sometimes I am sharing something I have read. Sometimes I am describing an idea I am trying to understand. Sometimes I am speaking from repeated experience. I want the person listening to know which of these they are receiving.

There is useful work in learning together. We can examine a question, compare observations and try something carefully. Saying, “This is how I currently understand it, and this is what I am still working through,” gives the other person room to participate with their own judgment.

I would rather make that room than let confidence in my explanation carry more weight than it deserves.

This is one reason I have chosen to continue working on my own understanding before taking on certain formal teaching responsibilities. I still sit with people, discuss questions and share what I can see. Those conversations help me learn too.

But taking responsibility for guiding someone through a subject asks something further of me. I want to understand what I can help them practise, how I would recognise progress, and where my own ability reaches its limits.

I have to apply this examination to ordinary working relationships as well.

If I encourage someone to speak openly, how do I respond when they tell me something uncomfortable? If I ask them to take responsibility, do I make my own commitments clear? If I talk about learning from mistakes, can we examine one of mine with the same openness?

The people around me have access to evidence that my explanation alone cannot provide.

This matters in what we are trying to build at K4M2A. I want our ideas to become available for examination through the way we work, the relationships we build and the responsibilities we fulfil.

People should be able to ask how we arrived at an understanding, what we have observed, and what we are still trying to make real. Their questions can help us see where our words have moved ahead of our ability.

That gap deserves attention.

When someone shows me a contradiction between my advice and my conduct, I want to be able to stay with it long enough to understand it. Explaining myself more convincingly will not, by itself, resolve what they have noticed.

The next step may be to practise something I have been recommending, revise an assumption, or become more modest about what I claim to know.

I want to offer advice with that responsibility in mind.

And if someone asks, “Can you show me what you mean?”, I want us to have something real to examine together.


Limitations

  • This reflects my own practice and experience, not a study.
  • It is about advice given in working relationships. Teaching, parenting or professional advice may ask for more, or for something different.

References

  1. First published on Medium, November 11, 2026
Write back to us

Whose advice do you trust most, and what have you seen that gives you reason to?

“The purpose of dialogue is not to win agreement, but to arrive at what is true.”

Related essays

More in this layer

All essays →